Skip to document

Control Theory and Conservative Criminology 7

These set of notes look at basic Criminal Theory perspective for examp...
Module

Criminological Theory (m900)

38 Documents
Students shared 38 documents in this course
Academic year: 2016/2017
Uploaded by:
62Uploads
132upvotes

Comments

Please sign in or register to post comments.

Related Studylists

Criminology with N

Preview text

Control Theory and Conservative Criminology 7/2/

Control Theory developed by American sociologist Travis Hurst n 1960s

Basic CT Perspective

CT informed by understanding of human nature, the idea that humans are rational and egoistic. Reason and self-interest govern human beings.

Rationality: efficient goal satisfaction, driven to pursue our self interet by whatever means are available to us. Unlike other creature’s human beings are also rational, therefore are able to decide the best way to get the things we desire.

Egoism: Self-interested hedonism

2 Consequences follow: (breaking the rules (crime) Rationality – rule breaking is it benefits outweigh the penalties Egoism – Rule breaking if the rules obstruct our goals

Crime happens when social controls fail for whatever reasons.

But for CT crime is also necessarily opportunistic. If we’re given the opportunity to break the rules, we’ll take the opportunity unless something stops us. There’s a growing super abundance of exciting goods that can be easily stolen. Since the war, there has been a growing volume of property that can be stolen.

Because crime is opportunistic and because we’ve seen an increase in opportunities available, for this reason crime has grown.

Travis Hirschi’s Social Control Theory

In Causes of Delinquences Hirschi argues: Social order based on regulation (social bonds) not integration (value commitments)

Our conformity is sustained on a day to day basis by our interactions with people. (church/school/workplace etc) This process of interaction involves the making and remaking of social bonds. The social bonds that link us with society operate as control mechanisms and these controls keep our egoistic desires controlled.

Hirschi argues there are four types of social bonds that ensure social conformity:

  • Attachment: Form an emotional bond with each other and with social institution. Individuals with conform is they form close emotional relations with significant others who are good role models. Primarily formed with parents, also with teachers. Hirschi doesn’t always mean a strong attachment with people who love each other. But more so provisional and superficial (school/workplace). Only if its seen as beneficial to us. Maintained only by regular ongoing relationships with institutions and only if the reaction of people reinforces that attachment.

  • Commitment: A sense of dedication we have to other people or institutions. Not necessari ly some deep internal dedication. Not self-sacrifice (egoistic) but the degree at which we devote time and energy to them and the degree at which they reward them. If we find commitments to institutions rewarding we commit to them if not we abandon them. Deviance happens when our social bond to institution weakens.

  • Involvement: Not emotionally apart of someone else. The effects of taking part. Wh ere we are participants in social institutions we will conform, takes away opportunities to deviate. Where we are not participants we are prone to deviate.

  • Belief: Degree to which we endorse the moral rules of society, but not saying we h ave a deep inner convictions that the rules we follow are right. Most of us don’t believe in anything passionately at all. Rather our beliefs of society are based on habit and around us. Beliefs that bind us to society can be easily dislodged, if they beliefs are incompatible with our interest we may disregard them.

Hirschi’s Self Control Theory

Hirschi later insisted that deviance:

  • Flourishes despite external controls
  • Results from weak internal controls

Crime and deliquency will sometimes happen even where the external bonds are strong. There are always people who are ill equipped to respond positively (low impulse control, psychological problem that creates deviance) Leads them into impulsive acts of self gratification without regard for consequences.

Self control theory necessary to explain key facts about crime and criminals:

  • Crime provides short term gratifications (quick buzz of excitement in response to boredom)
  • Criminal conduct includes full range of deviant acts
  • Crime is unplanned, unspecialised, and unsophisticated (don’t normally plan their law breaking)
  • Criminals are social failures (fail in school/relationships – rule breakers fail in everything that requires planning/sustained effort/post pone self-gratification)
  • Involvement in crime is stable and ongoing

Conclusion:

Crime occurs because people without internal (self) controls easier escape external controls

Dysfunctional families produce delinquents by failing to teach children self-discipline (fail to educate children, will end up with disadvantages, lack self-control (attracted to crime) etc)

Policy Implications

Reinforce traditional controls in society (more police, tougher law enforcement)

  • Increased police resources & powers

  • Expansion of prisons & community-based corrections

  • ‘Zero-tolerance’ law-enforcement (Wilson & Kelling, 1982)

  • ‘Designing out’ crime opportunities in urban spaces (improving personal & public security)

Was this document helpful?

Control Theory and Conservative Criminology 7

Module: Criminological Theory (m900)

38 Documents
Students shared 38 documents in this course
Was this document helpful?
Control Theory and Conservative Criminology 7/2/17
Control Theory developed by American sociologist Travis Hurst n 1960s
Basic CT Perspective
CT informed by understanding of human nature, the idea that humans are rational and egoistic.
Reason and self-interest govern human beings.
Rationality: efficient goal satisfaction, driven to pursue our self interet by whatever means are
available to us. Unlike other creature’s human beings are also rational, therefore are able to decide
the best way to get the things we desire.
Egoism: Self-interested hedonism
2 Consequences follow: (breaking the rules (crime)
Rationality – rule breaking is it benefits outweigh the penalties
Egoism – Rule breaking if the rules obstruct our goals
Crime happens when social controls fail for whatever reasons.
But for CT crime is also necessarily opportunistic. If we’re given the opportunity to break the rules,
we’ll take the opportunity unless something stops us.
There’s a growing super abundance of exciting goods that can be easily stolen. Since the war, there
has been a growing volume of property that can be stolen.
Because crime is opportunistic and because we’ve seen an increase in opportunities available, for
this reason crime has grown.
Travis Hirschi’s Social Control Theory
In Causes of Delinquences Hirschi argues:
Social order based on regulation (social bonds) not integration (value commitments)
Our conformity is sustained on a day to day basis by our interactions with people.
(church/school/workplace etc) This process of interaction involves the making and remaking of social
bonds. The social bonds that link us with society operate as control mechanisms and these controls
keep our egoistic desires controlled.
Hirschi argues there are four types of social bonds that ensure social conformity:
- Attachment: Form an emotional bond with each other and with social institution.
Individuals with conform is they form close emotional relations with significant others who
are good role models. Primarily formed with parents, also with teachers.
Hirschi doesn’t always mean a strong attachment with people who love each other. But more
so provisional and superficial (school/workplace). Only if its seen as beneficial to us.
Maintained only by regular ongoing relationships with institutions and only if the reaction of
people reinforces that attachment.
- Commitment: A sense of dedication we have to other people or institutions. Not necessarily
some deep internal dedication. Not self-sacrifice (egoistic) but the degree at which we
devote time and energy to them and the degree at which they reward them. If we find
commitments to institutions rewarding we commit to them if not we abandon them.
Deviance happens when our social bond to institution weakens.